If you’ve tried Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara, then you may love the lengthening, volumizing, and curling properties. It’s a cult favorite for a reason since it can give you gorgeous lashes in just one coat. But it does come with a hefty price tag.
Luckily the drugstore has upped its game in recent years when it comes to quality makeup, including mascara. I found 10 Better Than Sex Mascara dupes that will save you money without sacrificing quality.
This post contains affiliate links, and any purchases made through these links will result in a commission for me at no extra cost to you. Please read my Disclosure for additional information.
So what makes Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara so good? Let’s take a look:
Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara
Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara is the #1 selling prestige mascara in the US. This buildable mascara is loved for its ability to create long lashes with luxe volume and curl with each coat you apply.
The formula contains film-forming polymers to keep your curl in place.
Acacia Senegal Gum is a natural polymer that thickens and binds, so it helps to set your volume.
A peptide works to condition your lashes and give them a deep, dark black shade. (The mascara only comes in one black shade.)
The weighty hourglass-shaped brush is designed to separate each lash as it coats and curls.
The mascara lifts your lashes while coating the top and bottom of each lash.
Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara also comes in a waterproof version if you’re looking for a long-wearing volumizing, and lengthening waterproof mascara.
10 Best Better Than Sex Mascara Dupes
If you want the same fantastic lash volume and length as Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara, but don’t want to spend as much for it, then check out some of these drugstore mascara dupes that will surely save you money.
1. L’Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara
L’Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara (shown in Black Brown) is my pick for the best Too Faced Better Than Sex mascara dupe.
Forget the fact that the tube looks strikingly similar to Too Faced because the gorgeous dramatic results speak for themselves.
Lash Paradise Mascara provides instant volume and length to your lashes without clumping.
Floral oil conditions and softens lashes so your lashes won’t be hard or crunchy. Your full lengthened lashes will last up to 24 hours.
You’ll notice that the wand has a wavy shape similar to the Too Faced shape.
The brush contains soft bristles that ensure that each and every lash is evenly coated with mascara.
Because it doesn’t have as much of an hourglass shape as Too Faced, it can be a bit more challenging to apply, but once applied, it’s smudge-resistant and easy to remove.
The mascara comes in four shades: Black, Blackest Black, Mystic Black, and Black Brown. If you prefer waterproof mascara, you can try Lash Paradise Waterproof Mascara.
If you want to improve your mascara wear, you can pair one of the shades with Lash Paradise Mascara Primer/Base, a pink-tinted mascara primer that improves the wear of your mascara.
2. CoverGirl Exhibitionist Mascara
CoverGirl Exhibitionist Mascara (shown in the shade Black Brown) is a volumizing mascara that creates thick, bold lashes.
The wand has an hourglass shape, just like Too Faced. Only one coat creates longer lashes with striking definition and separation without the clumpiness of some mascaras.
You won’t notice any flaking or smudging, either.
CoverGirl notes that this lengthening mascara volumizes like the #1 Prestige Mascara.
Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara is the #1 Prestige Mascara, as previously mentioned!
I personally love CoverGirl mascaras (especially their LashBlash Clean mascara) when I want to create natural-looking but defined eyelashes.
But this mascara really delivers a more dramatic look with noticeable length, volume, and lash separation.
This mascara comes in the shades Black, Very Black, Black Brown, and Midnight Black.
If you like the original but want waterproof coverage, try CoverGirl Exhibitionist Waterproof Mascara in Very Black.
3. Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara (shown in the shade Black) allows you to use your own lashes to create that falsies lash look we love.
The fiber brush is conical-shaped to lift and lengthen lashes. Lashes look fuller, thicker, and very voluminous.
The mascara is formulated to avoid fading and flaking throughout the day, so your lashes will look fabulous all day and into the night.
This is one of Essence’s most popular mascaras, and it’s easy to see why.
The results are beautiful and dramatic, without being over the top and clumpy-looking.
Maybe not quite like real false lashes, but very noticeably glam.
The one drawback is that this volumizing and lifting mascara comes in just one shade: Black. It does, however, come in a waterproof version.
This drugstore dupe is SO cheap that you can buy multiple tubes for the price of one Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara.
4. Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara (shown in the shade True Brown) is all about length and volume, just like Better Than Sex Mascara.
Even though the brush is different from Too Faced (Maybelline’s Flex Tower brush bends to coat each and every lash), the effect is the same: thick, long lashes that don’t smudge or flake throughout the day.
The formula contains bamboo extract and fibers to ensure that your lashes are full and voluminous.
Apply multiple layers from root to tip for a more dramatic look.
This lengthening mascara is available in the shades Blackest Black, Cosmic Black, Very Black, and True Brown. The mascara also comes in multiple waterproof shades.
The mascara is suitable for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes, as it’s been allergy and ophthalmologist-tested.
5. Elf Big Mood Mascara
Elf Big Mood Mascara (shown in the shade Black) is a lifting and volumizing mascara that has a similar hourglass-shaped mascara brush as Too Faced.
Big Mood Mascara is my NEW FAVORITE Better Than Sex Mascara dupe due to its low price, high-volume look, and long-lasting wear!
Elf Big Mood Mascara is designed to give you flawless, volumized lashes and is very affordably priced.
It’s formulated with jojoba oil, which conditions your lashes, promoting lash health and growth.
The mascara wand lifts and separates your lashes for a dramatic, wide-eyed look.
With its smudge-proof and flake-resistant formula, it ensures long-lasting wear that works from morning to night.
The mascara comes in the shades Black, Pitch Black, Deep Brown, and the colors Deep Green, Bold Blue, and a Waterproof version.
6. L’Oreal Bambi Eye Mascara
For a stunning, wide-eyed look, L’Oreal Bambi Eye Mascara (shown in the shade Blackest Black) lifts, curls, and volumizes your lashes, opening up your eyes for a striking lash effect.
No clumping or flaking here!
This little gem’s unique velvet brush skillfully glides over every single lash, coating them for that perfect fanned-out look.
It comes with a brush fitted with both short and long bristles. This meticulous design ensures every lash, from root to tip, gets coated with mascara.
The smudge-proof formula has got you covered – you can wear it all day without the need for those pesky touch-ups.
Bambi Eye comes in a washable and waterproof shades:
- Washable: Blackest Black, Black, Black Brown, and Extra Noir
- Waterproof: Black, Blackest Black
7. L’Oreal Voluminous Million Lashes Mascara
L’Oréal Voluminous Million Lashes Mascara (shown in the shade Blackest Black) is your secret weapon to achieving voluminous, defined lashes that steal the spotlight, just like Too Faced.
Designed to catch every lash, from corner to corner, the clever Millionizer Brush ensures clump-free application for a look that’s high on volume and high on drama.
It features a unique “Clean Sweep Wiping System” that effortlessly clears excess mascara, leaving just the right amount on your brush for beautifully bold lashes.
Voluminous Million Lashes Mascara is available in four washable shades: Black, Blackest Black, Black Brown, and Carbon Black.
8. L’Oreal Voluminous Original Mascara
L’Oreal’s Voluminous Original Mascara (shown in the shade Black Brown) creates lashes that are up to 5x thicker and separated to perfection.
L’Oreal’s Volume Maximizing Brush thickens your lashes while keeping away those annoying clumps. Your lashes will feel super soft and flake-free all day long.
This L’Oreal mascara is infused with panthenol and ceramide-R to protect and condition your lashes. I love the length and fullness this mascara offers.
This best-selling mascara comes in a large range of shades, too, including colors like Cobalt Blue, Deep Burgundy, Deep Green, and Deep Violet.
9. Flower Warrior Princess Mascara
Flower Warrior Princess Mascara (shown in Royal Black) lets your lashes take the throne with gorgeous volume and lift.
Just like Too Faced, the hourglass brush ensures each and every lash is treated to the silky smooth, clump-free formula, lifting from root to tip for a gorgeous lash look.
The mascara comes in just one shade: Royal Black, which is highly pigmented for the ultimate dark, dramatic lashes.
10. Rimmel ScandalEyes Mascara
Rimmel ScandalEyes Mascara (shown in the shade Extreme Black) is a long-wearing mascara that creates volume and length in just one coat.
The brush has a tapered end, so it really allows you to get every lash, even the tiniest lashes on your lower lid.
The formula is buildable, so you can keep layering the mascara until you get your desired look.
The mascara is infused with hydrolyzed collagen, which helps to condition and moisturize your lashes.
Argan oil, panthenol (pro-vitamin B5), and vitamin E also help to keep your lashes healthy and moisturized.
This drugstore mascara dupe is easy to remove at the end of the day, so there’s no tugging or pulling at your delicate lashes.
The mascara comes in two shades: Black and Extreme Black, and there is also a waterproof version.
Related Post: The Ordinary Multi-Peptide Lash And Brow Serum Review
Final Thoughts on Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara Dupes
As you can see from these mascara dupes, Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara has some serious competition!
These high-quality, more affordable mascaras will give you the lengthened, volumized, and defined lashes you want – all without breaking the bank.
To read more about reviving your dried-out mascara, see this post on how to fix dry mascara.
So if you’re looking for an excellent mascara that will make your lashes look longer and fuller, be sure to check out one of these affordable options.
Have you tried any of these Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara dupes? What did you think? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
Want more makeup dupes? Check out these posts:
Thanks for reading!
Sarah Roberts is the founder, writer, and photographer behind A Beauty Edit. With over 10 years of experience in the beauty industry, Sarah is an avid skincare and beauty enthusiast who shares the best beauty finds to help you save time and money!